IMF Programme #17: takes two to tango

March, 20, 2023

On Sri Lanka’s reform-regress-run to the IMF crisis cycle

By Daniel Alphonsus

Countries never learn from others’ mistakes, they only learn from their own. Sri Lanka is an exception: we don’t even learn from our folly. Apparently neither does the IMF. Sri Lanka’s 17th IMF programme is set to be approved on March 20th. Is it welcome? Yes. Will it break Sri Lanka’s reform-regress-run to the IMF crisis cycle? Probably not.

All reforms undertaken over the past half-year to win IMF board approval are reversible. None of them constitute entrenched changes in economic policy or governance. We are building our recovery on the shakiest of foundations. The fuel and electricity price ‘formulae’, tax plus interest rate increases and greater exchange rate flexibility can all be altered, more or less, at the stroke of a pen.   

This is not surprising. Sri Lanka has a chequered history of cosmetic compliance: ticking the boxes of virtue and sensibility via international undertakings during desperate times, and then reverting to business-as-usual once crisis abates. We have good reason to think that, this time too, the future will rhyme with this past. Undoubtedly, post IMF board approval, some reforms less easy to rewind will come to pass - the new Central Bank Act being the most notable.

But the IMF’s bargaining power peaks prior to board approval. That is the decisive point in this process. It is the pivotal moment for any attempt to use this crisis to build the foundations required for breaking the crisis cycle and going from third-world to first. If the most contentious and critical reforms are not pushed through prior to board approval, there is good reason to think they will not come to pass. Remember that of its 16 programmes thus far, Sri Lanka’s has only completed two extended / structural programmes. The remainder are either relatively insignificant standby-facilities or derailed extended programmes 

Considering the unprecedented nature of the current crisis, this is a colossal missed opportunity. As argued in a prequel article, Programme 17 could have and should have broken this cycle. Public opinion was desperate, the government commanded a super-majority in Parliament and the IMF held all the aces. The distinction between what is desirable and what is feasible had, almost overnight, dissolved. The cry for fuel and electricity was so piercing and loud that a comprehensive and deep programme permitting profound economic restructuring was possible for the first time since 1977.

Moreover, even if some of the required reforms come to fruition over Programme 17’s next few reviews - it will still be a missed opportunity. Reform takes time, effort and energy. These are scarce resources. As major structural reforms - such as the central bank act, fiscal rules, privatisations and labour market reforms - were not completed as prior actions, it means the first few reviews will be focussed on them. This will leave little room for some of the more complex long-term reforms; especially in land, the public service and regulatory policy (e.g. competition policy).

Of course, we are a sovereign state, so primary responsibility for this failure lies in our own polity. But we find little hope in ourselves. As weary and jaded citizens we tend to assume inertia, or worse, on our side as a given. Which is why this article is about the IMF’s failure.  

What could the IMF had done differently? Especially considering its familiarity with Buenos Aires, it should know that it takes two to tango. As Keynes famously said of the IMF and World Bank; the Bank’s a fund, and the Fund’s a bank. Considering the creditor-borrower relationship between the IMF and Sri Lanka; as a creditor the IMF should bear some responsibility for the failure of so many programmes over such a long period of time. The IMF’s own kapuralas have conceived of programme conditionality as a form of collateral. The IMF ought demand more conditionality as collateral prior to lending. This, of course, requires review of past country programmes and, as we all know, economic history and country expertise are not exactly first-rank priorities at the Fund.

Anyone involved in economic policy-making in Sri Lanka, the IMF included of course, knows that much of the technical work was already done. When the staff-level agreement was signed in September last year, there was a great deal of reform that just required political will and nothing else. Cabinet had approved an earlier version of the new central bank bill during the last days of the Samaraweera ministry. Placing energy price formulas on a statutory footing shouldn’t take more than a day’s drafting. Fiscal rules legislation was already in a relatively advanced stage. Non-legislative measures could also have been mandated - the state could readily have divested its stakes in Sri Lanka Telecom and Lanka Hospitals. These firms are already listed with established valuations. Considering the 200 days between the staff-level agreement in September and board approval now, we had more than enough time to list the major state banks and Sri Lanka Insurance; maybe even privatize the East, Jaya and Unity container terminals. After all, for better or worse, remember the plantations were effectively privatized within fourty-eight hours. These delays are all the more astonishing due to the hypocrisy of asking for favours from our creditors while refusing to sell underperforming assets.  

Primary balance vs growth

Considering the political cost of market pricing energy and increasing taxes, from a political point of view, there is tremendous incentive for the political leadership to undertake structural reform in return for less pain. Sri Lanka’s future debt sustainability (or lack thereof) is a function of current and future (a) government revenue, (b) government expenditure and (c) GDP growth. By raising Sri Lanka’s growth potential, both the IMF and long-term creditors could and should have been willing to trade-off revenue and expenditure targets for entrenched, high quality structural reform. The one percent rate hike - which the central bank opposed - just before placing Sri Lanka on the board agenda illustrates this well. Clearly, this temporary, one-off one percent increase in interest rates was considered decisive for obtaining board approval. Why then was not actually passing the central bank bill in Parliament - which is likely to shape inflation rates for decades?[1] Note that in my view, the IMF’s bargaining power at this juncture could be so strong that a trade-off between primary balance linked targets and structural reforms may not exist. The IMF may have been able to demand both. That is the IMF could have had the cake, eaten the cake and called it a letter of intent.

Primary balance today vs primary balance tomorrow

Even if one does not buy the argument of reducing the primary balance target today in exchange for growth tomorrow, two strategies superior to the status quo could have been pursued.

First, instead of trading off the primary balance versus growth, we could have exchanged a primary balance improvement today for a larger primary balance improvement tomorrow. The IMF could have permitted reducing the primary balance target today in exchange for entrenched reforms that result in a paradigm shift in Sri Lanka’s primary balance trajectory for the future. For example, coming back to the central bank bill, through greater depoliticization and limitations on central bank funding of government deficits, this landmark reform is likely to change Sri Lanka’s medium to long term primary balance trajectory. The ‘net present value’ of this change in primary balance terms - even when discounted for the probability of it being unenforced - is likely to be greater than a few percentage point changes in the primary balance today.

Optimizing this trade-off would also have the added benefit of placing less pain on the public and reducing the extent of contractionary policy amidst Sri Lanka’s worst economic crisis in decades.

Second, there are some measures that can improve the primary balance today, and tomorrow. A good example is the sale of shares in state banks. The sale of minority stakes in BOC and People’s Bank will raise money for the exchequer, boosting the primary surplus. However, especially if the banks are listed, it will also make it more difficult for the state banks to permit the government to create enormous contingent liabilities via loans to the CEB and CPC, resulting in a healthier future primary balance.

Overdiscounting the future

The argument often made in response is that the IMF cannot tradeoff the certainty of hitting quantitative targets today, in return for structural reforms whose fruits may not materialize tomorrow. This view is misguided. First, deep understanding of context enables a reasonably good assessment of the probabilities of a structural reform producing a desired outcome - enabling the computation of rough expected values. For example, we know that once a privatization takes place it is unlikely to be easily undone. Second, even after first discounting on the basis of probabilities, a second round of discounting can take place to compensate - to some degree - for the uncertainty inherent in structural reform.[2]

Bailamos

There are two dancers in this toxic tango. They both need to take stock of the past, break with it and dance a new dance. Introspection is a good start. The IMF and our government should get together and commission a review of all past programmes to inform the design and implementation of the current programme. In the meantime, the priority should be to ensure as many structural reforms as possible are pushed through prior to the first review. If we are able to use entrenched, high-quality structural reform to credibly improve Sri Lanka’s medium term growth and primary balance trajectory, we should be able to avoid some of the short-term pain and contraction that we would otherwise experience. Then, maybe instead of toxic tango, we can look forward to a solid baila session. With the President, as he did with Iranganie Serasinghe, accompanying the IMF’s managing director for a round of kaffirhina. After all, compared to austerity, structural reform is a sumhiri pane.

Daniel Alphonsus is the Director at Advocata Institute. The opinions expressed are the author’s own views. They may not necessarily reflect the views of the Advocata Institute or anyone affiliated with the institute.

 

[1] I don’t know enough about the IMF except to speculate, in the most general terms, that perhaps the concern with a measurable, quantitative target for debt sustainability trumps the by definition, less certain judgment call of the impact of a reform like the central bank bill on long-term inflation rates. But this prioritization of precision with performance gives rise to a short-term bias.

[2] These two points can be illustrated using the example of the primary balance vs a new central bank act. Suppose, for a moment, that we are are indifferent between a 1% increase in the primary balance today or a 2% increase tomorrow. Let us also suppose that the new central bank act will increase the primary balance by 5% tomorrow. Then we should choose the new central bank act. Now let us add probabilities in. Lets say the probability of the new central act increasing the primary balance tomorrow by 5% is 80%. Then the expected change in tomorrow’s primary balance is 5%*80%, which is 4%. Let us also discount a little - say 25% -for uncertainty in the probability estimate since we may want to be risk averse. Therefore, the expected change in tomorrow’s primary balance, discounting for uncertainty, is 3%. This means, if our objective is minimizing the primary deficit over time, we should still choose the central bank act over a 1% increase in the primary balance today.

 

Video Story

A Crisis If Economy Does Not Grow – Sujeewa Mudalige & Talal RafiLiberal Handling of Market Will Continue | Duminda HulangamuwaTax exemptions have not served very well for SL - IMF's Peter Breuer ‘At Hydepark’SL tourism to showcase a new era of growth at WTM 2024 in LondonExclusive Interview with Dr. Nandalal Weerasinghe at Ada Derana Hyde ParkThe Nightly Business Report |17th May 2024The Nightly Business Report | 15th May 2024The Nightly Business Report | 13th May 2024The Nightly Business Report | 07 May 2024The Nightly Business Report | 30th April 2024The Nightly Business Report | 29th April 2024The Nightly Business Report | 26th April 2024The Nightly Business Report | 25th April 2024The Nightly Business Report | 22nd April 2024The Nightly Business Report | 19th April 2024The Nightly Business Report | 17th April 2024The Nightly Business Report | 16th April 2024The Nightly Business Report | 15th April 2024RICH MUST PAY MORE TAXES, IMF’S PETER BREUER & SARWAT JAHAN ‘AT HYDEPARK WITH INDEEWARI AMUWATTE’2024 Will Have More Positivity – CBSL Governor Dr. Nandalal Weerasinghe ‘@ HYDEPARKBudget 2024 - Dr. Roshan PereraWhat's happening to tourism ?SALIYA PIERIS & NALAKA GUNAWARDENE ON SL ONLINE SAFETY BILL - 'AT HYDEPARK WITH INDEEWARI AMUWATTE’Ravi Abeysuriya and Deshan Pushparajah join Indeewari Amuwatte 'At HydePark' on Ada Derana 24Former IMF-ICD director Dr. Sharmini Coorey joins Indeewari Amuwatte 'at HYDEPARK' on Ada Derana 24Dr. Priyanga Dunusinghe and Dr. Nadeem Ul Haque join Indeewari Amuwatte At HydeParkHEAD OF SOE RESTRUCTURING UNIT SURESH SHAH JOINS INDEEWARI AMUWATTE 'AT HYDEPARK' ON ADA DERANA 24Sri Lanka: Supporting Recovery and Promoting Stable & Inclusive GrowthCBSL Governor is confident that Sri Lanka will be able to achieve debt sustainability even before the timeframe envisaged through the IMF EFF programmeCSE had a bullish start for the week but later drop in prices capped early gains of the dayForeign Investors resulted a net foreign inflow of LKR 230 millionCSE continued to move upward ahead of monetary policy review meetingCSE records downward trend for second consecutive dayThe current tax policy is a rescue operation - PresidentCSE managed to secure its bull run for 2nd consecutive session in the weekCSE’s ASPI records massive gain - 20.02.2022Sri Lanka Stock Market 13.02.2023Sri Lanka Stock Market 10.02.2023Sri Lanka Stock Market 08.02.2023Sri Lanka Stock Market 03.02.2023Sri Lanka Stock Market 02.02.2023Govt needs to have a policy framework to bring about the necessary change - Ranjit PageSri Lanka Stock Market 26.01.2023Sri Lanka Stock Market 24.01.2023Sri Lanka Stock Market 20.01.2023Sri Lanka Stock Market 18.01.2023Sri Lanka Stock Market 13.01.2023Sri Lanka Stock Market 12.01.2023Alternative solutions for Sri Lanka's economic recovery - Dr. Howard Nicholas, EconomistSri Lanka Stock Market 10. 01. 2023Sri Lanka Stock Market 09.01.2023Sri Lanka Stock Market 04.01.2023Sri Lanka Stock Market 03.01.2023IMF bailout package can be approved by the global lender in January 2023 by which time Sri Lanka would have secured creditor assurances from countries including India and China – CBSL GovernorADA DERANA POST-BUDGET DISCUSSION ON 'RECOVERING FROM CRISIS, REGAINING STABILITY'CSE Chairman says they expect to introduce a host of new financial instruments to the Colombo Bourse by mid-2023Sri Lanka’s Turnaround Strategies and the Role of the International CommunityPresident Ranil addresses Sri Lankan diaspora in UKUSAID ADMINISTRATOR SAMANTHA POWER WITH INDEEWARI AMUWATTE AT HYDEPARK ON ADA DERANA 24PETROLEUM ENGINEER SALIYA WICKRAMASURIYA JOINS INDEEWARI AMUWATTE AT HYDEPARK ON ADA DERANA 24US Ambassador to Sri Lanka Julie Chung Joins Indeewari Amuwatte at Hydepark on Ada Derana 24Press Conference on Current Economic SituationSri Lanka may take weeks to hire debt advisers, Sabry saysExpert Panel of Industrialists Join Indeewari Amuwatte @HydeparkExperts Discuss How to Best Address Sri Lanka’s Economic Situation with Indeewari Amuwatte @HYDEPARK@Hyde Park with Indeewari Amuwatta | Srimathi ShivashankarHow can Sri Lanka reset and revive its economy while finding solutions to address a health crisis?CBSL Governor Ajith Nivard Cabraal Joins Indeewari Amuwatte @HYDEPARKU.S. Ambassador to Sri Lanka Alaina B. Teplitz says that Sri Lanka should choose its partners based on openness, transparency and true investments rather than loans.We're not taking anything away from investors - SEC ChairmanEconomic Freedom of Sri LankaCSE Chairman Dumith Fernando Joins Indeewari Amuwatte @Hydepark on Ada Derana 24Inaugural speech by His Excellency President Gotabaya Rajapaksa at Sri Lanka Economic Summit 2020US SEC. of State Mike Pompeo Joins Indeewari Amuwatte @Hydepark on Ada Derana 24Foreign Secretary Joins Indeewari Amuwatte @HYDEPARK on Ada Derana 24GET REAL - Senior Deputy Governor of the Central Bank of Sri Lanka Dr. Nandalal WeerasingheMAS joins global efforts to contain spread of COVID-19Preventing Disruptions to Economic Activity amidst the Spread of the COVID-19 PandemicDUMITH FERNANDO JOINS INDEEWARI AMUWATTE @HYDEPARK ON ADA DERANA 24FORMER CBSL GOVERNOR AJITH NIVARD CABRAAL JOINS INDEEWARI AMUWATTE @HYDEPARK ON ADA DERANA 24BE BOLD! DR. MARK MOBIUS TELLS SRI LANKASri Lanka urgently needs a nation branding strategy that will help the island nation be a game-changer - Dr. Udaya IndrarathnaLotus Tower officially declared openAgreement signed to develop East container terminal at Colombo PortUpdate from Washington: US Foreign Policy towards China and South Asia and what it means for Sri LankaEaster Day attacks are a blow in the economy at large, not just tourism industryILO Launches Report on the Future of Work in Sri LankaMacroeconomic Impact of the Budget 2019Fiscal Impact of the Budget 2019Harry Jayawardena @ KPMG's post Budget ForumDissecting Budget 2019Sri Lanka Economic Association – Annual Sessions 2018Land reclamation for Port City completedSri Lanka Targeting 3 Million Tourists in 2019Susantha Ratnayake bids farewell to JKH, Balendra junior in as ChairmanThe economy cannot operate isolation - PallewattaDo we have the money to pay our obligations coming due next year? Answer is yes.CBSL Governor Dr. Indrajit Coomaraswamy, addressing 22nd Annual General Meeting of the ACGMr. Ranjit Page addressing the 2nd Annual General Meeting of the Sri Lanka Retailers’ AssociationCentral Bank issues a new series of coinsUS$ 184 million spent to defend Rupee - CBSL GovernorSri Lanka PM Ranil ‘Concerned on rebalancing of the Global Order’ at World Economic Forum on ASEANSri Lanka Economic Summit 2018 - Keynote Address Mr. Arun M Kumar - Chairman and CEO, KPMG IndiaSL at risk of exchange rate crisis - NomuraSumal Perera suggests Dhammika Perera should be the Next Presidential Candidate at Fireside ChatSL's IT/BPM Marks $1.2 Bn in Revenue - EDBContent creators can now monetize via YouTube in Sri Lanka!There are about 20 other reports like of the bond scam - Auditor GeneralA rapid development in coming 18 months - PMEconomic growth cannot be achieved with a small marketSL Rupee should be allowed to float – IMFSri Lanka highly important in terms of business in South Asia - Petri PeltonenSri Lanka blessed with rich natural resources we can only dream about - Harri KämäräinenGovt planning new national economic strategy – Prof. Lalith SamarakoonSri Lanka rupee hits record lowMonetary Board decides to reduce SLFR by 25 bpsEU delegation highlights need for further progress on human rightsTourism Minister requests diplomats to invite countrymen to visit SLSri Lanka statistics office withdraws GDP dataJapan-Sri Lanka Business Forum held under President's patronageEvening with a Corporate Leader : Mr Dhammika PereraThere is scarcity of talent - Kathy Tingate, Director HR, Microsoft Asia PacificGas cylinder prices to be increased?Budget Openness: Sri Lanka Needs Higher StandardsStock Market continues strong start to the year with the second listing of 2018United States GSP program expires on Dec 31President to request Russia to withdraw tea banJAT Holdings could go public in SingaporeLVL Energy Fund announces Rs. 1.2 billion IPO to fund its strategic growth and expansionWe still haven't found all the dead bodies - PMA budget office to be established in parliament by the end of 2018 - Minister EranWe have a serious concern about debt distress – CBSL GovernorPetroleum Minister Arjuna Ranatunga explains cause for fuel shortageAnika Wijesuriya has fled country due to threats - AG's DeptSri Lanka and Finland to ink agreement on digitalizationMorison PLC unveiled to mark new eraDSL Enterprises joins with Little Hearts social welfare projectPM inaugurates largest naval vessel to be produced in SLAG's dept grills PTL legal officers over litigation errorPresident declares open star class hotel in Nuwara EliyaFormer CB Governor questioned on Greek bond investmentsNew Inland Revenue Bill to be tabled on FridayRevelations at treasury bond commission by former EPF SuperintendentBOI should be closed down - Justice MinisterAloysius asked to hand over personal electronic devices to bond commissionSri Lanka Customs launches online payment platform for declarationsSri Lanka’s tallest building gets shaky from the startBeneficiaries of EPF will have to pay taxes - BandulaWe need an export oriented economy - PMRavi Karunanayake on why he switched from finance to foreign affairsSL looking to import fabric to meet new demand due to GSP+ - Felix Fernando18% duty on fish exports to be lifted under GSP+GSP+ is granted to encourage govt. towards reforms - Tung-Lai MargueNew tax revenue proposal to increase government coffers - RaviDHL is committed to enhancing its investments in SLHambantota port deal is a major plus, will benefit country - CB GovernorDerana launches Derana SME Club with IDBWe will bring in new legislation – PMSL’s first A320 touches down at BIAAll securities issued by the government are absolutely safe – CB GovernorSri Lanka spending Rs 35 billion to import milk powder - HarshaGoogle internet balloon plan hits a legal snag - HarinLAUGFS Creates History at HambantotaFinance Minister calls CB Governor a hospital attendant - VIDEOEPF can buy over all companies in Sri Lanka, says Premier – VIDEOHandunnetti questions how Perpetual Treasuries gained heavenly wisdom – VIDEOLondon Stock Exchange Group opens new technology facility in Sri Lanka - VIDEO
The requested content cannot be found
A Crisis If Economy Does Not Grow – Sujeewa Mudalige & Talal Rafi

Stock Market

Exchange Rates